I think it was the French poet Paul Vallery who said there are no new ideas, only variations of old ones. I wonder if he was thinking of his own poetry when he said that.
It’s hard to imagine The Beatles’ Let it Be being a variation of an old theme, or the intro to The Moody Blues’ Nights in White Satin being music we have heard before, but the same and different in subtle ways from other compositions.
This is difficult to argue against for me as I am often inspired to write lyrics after having listened to a song. I can imagine I am not alone in doing so. In fact, I once got a tip from someone I consider to be a premier songwriter, a person whom I give my highest respect. He said, when writing lyrics, put a melody in your head from a song similar to your idea, and then compose the music different from the melody you used as a model.
A novel idea, one I have used from time to time. Now, of course, I am not the one composing the music, but it works just the same.
When I first started writing songs, they were quirky, original, but lacked rhythm. My songwriting partner, Ed, didn’t notice or care. He would occasionally change something to make it fall into place better, and had the green light to do so. I swear, Ed amazes me how he comes up with melodies.
Then I got to know John Delk. If you don’t know his work, check him out on Sound Cloud (link below).
We occasionally write songs together, and whenever I am stuck I call upon him. He is always a joy to work with, and a real gentleman.
John writes these wonderfully rhythmic lyrics. When listening to one of John’s songs I have great expectation what the next line will be, the next rhyme, and his choruses are always spot on. Just wonderfully melodic.
Give a listen to Broke Down in Tupelo, Coupe deVille and A Gallon at a Time, or any of his songs. I aspire to write lyrics as beautifully rhythmic and melodic as these.
John Delk on Sound Cloud
But if you listen to Monsieur Vallery, all of John’s songs have been done before, kinda sorta.
Nah…no way!!!